My wife and I stayed at Villa Eden for 3 nights in October of 2022. It was our sixth visit to Cozumel, and Villa Eden was the nicest place we have stayed by far. The ocean-front location is amazing. When we weren't on the dive boat, we were likely sitting on the ocean-front deck enjoying the incredible view. Or going for a swim in the ocean. Or sitting in the hot tub.
Communication from the property managers was excellent; Ronen, Fulvio, and Genny. The house and grounds were clean and well maintained. The beds and linens were very comfortable. The AC worked great. In addition, everything was super quiet, which was really important to us (we had a poor experience at a recent *different* Cozumel lodging due to noise from partying). So - the only thing that would make us hesitate about staying at Villa Eden again is the proximity of two other properties that are suitable for large groups. The properties are essentially just a few feet away from Villa Eden. To be clear, for our stay, things were very quiet - and perhaps we are over-sensitive due to our other recent experience - but having a property just a few feet away that appears to cater to weddings, parties, etc made us fearful that a group was going to roll in any minute and destroy the Villa Eden peaceful sanctuary.