We rented this house for a last minute holiday weekend trip to BHI. Our group consisted of 2 families with 2 young children each (4 adults, 4 children total). The house was very comfortable for us all. The kids loved the 2 big rooms upstairs with their own bathrooms while the adults didn't have to be worried about being too loud after the kids went to bed. We truly had no complaints about the house. It is a super private setting so it feels very peaceful, but you're just down the road from everything. There were plenty of games for the kids to play for when we weren't at the beach, and it was very nice to have plenty of beach gear for us to use while we were there: chairs, umbrella, boogie boards, skim boards, etc... I think each adult in our group at some point mentioned how nice the setup was.
Brandy was great to work with and very helpful after a scheduling error forced us from our first rental. She made everything easy and painless, and was also very attentive during the weekend. Overall we were very pleased!