A truly lovely place to escape from it all. The house is beautiful, the staff unbelievably helpful/friendly, and the location unbeatable. It really is like having your own private island. But definitely not the place to go if you're looking for creature comforts — there are no restaurants available to you (COMO no longer allows access to theirs, so be prepared to do all your own cooking), the limited AC is very overmatched by the tropical heat/open layout, and the pest problem is VERY apparent (understandable for an older house in the tropics, but not at this price point).
In sum, I would give it a 6 out of 5 based on location/the charm of house/the beauty of the island, but only a 3 out of 5 on all other metrics (and frankly, that's generous). I truly wish I could give this place a perfect review, as the days really were absolutely amazing, but the rest of the experience was simply too much to overlook.