We rented this cabin for my family and my sister's family for Christmas. Island Park was magical, the snow was amazing and we found the cabin to be comfortable. We loved the location! I loved the fireplace and large windows opening up to the loft.
We had the same problems with the hot tub as listed in other reviews. It was not clean and the chlorine was so high. We spent a couple of hours on Christmas Eve cleaning it. After calling the owners they did tell us where the chemicals were but they didn't have the right ones to fix the chlorine so that was a bummer.
Before checking in I dealt with a managing company, they were fine except I asked them on three different occasions if the house would have Christmas trees since most places we have rented in the past over the holidays have provided a tree. They told me due to covid restrictions there wouldn't be trees, so I packed our tree up and brought it with us. When we arrived there were two trees set up - which was fun, but the tree I packed had taken up a lot of room in our vehicle so that was a bit frustrating. If you don't care about the hot tub, this location is perfect - the cabin is pretty and has all of the basics you will need. Bringing our own water to supplement what was provided wasn't a big deal. We enjoyed our Christmas here.