I can't say enough positive things about Low Key Penthouse. It looks exactly as it does in the pictures... and if you travel much, you know that this isn't always the case. Literally across the path from Coco Bay, which is probably the best swimming beach on GTC (great snorkeling, too! Lots to see). Public dock within a few hundred feet makes renting a boat for exploring other cays easy and convenient.
A fun golf cart ride away from New Plymouth, and super short ride to Ballyhoo and the Beach Bar, which were our absolute favorite hangouts for food and drinks. If you are craving being where the action is or being able to walk to a bar, this location might not be the best for you. BUT, if you are seeking quiet, easy beach access, and short, easy rides to bars and town, this place is IDEAL.
The owner was very easy to communicate with and gave very quick replies. We only rented the upstairs, which was thoughtfully stocked and well cared for. For a few days of our week-long stay, there were other renters in the lower half of the house, but both units have a lot of privacy and we really never knew they were there. Kitchen was fully equipped and I couldn't think of anything that wasn't provided. They even had bug spray and sun block- but I highly recommend bringing a lot of both of these, yourself. Depending on where you are on the cay, the little gnats can be quite persistent! Laundry facilities and an outdoor shower are on the property, too. Loved the screened in porch.
Honestly, I can't think of anything that would make this a better location to stay on GTC!