We just returned from a weekend in Edgartown and were very pleased with the size, comfort & location of this property. Less than a 10 minute walk from downtown and with the super convenient Katama General Store around the corner, it was easy to get around. The pictures don't even show the adorable breakfast nook, and the sunny window seat was by far my favorite spot to sit. I had asked for early checkin weeks prior via email and never heard back but we took a chance and was pleasantly surprised when we were able to check in at 2pm. I am not one to complain, but the shower was the worst part of the cottage. The mixing valve was broken, so I either could choose a freezing cold shower with no pressure or a scalding hot one. Not to mention the shower curtain was covered in mildew, something that's an easy fix, but nonetheless a disappointment. From the previous reviews, I knew that the accommodations were going to have a stuffy smell to it and that was accurate. You got used to it but it was a bit overwhelming upon entering the house. Thank goodness for the space heater & extra blanket, it got down to the 30s overnight and it was freezing! All in all, I would definitely stay again & recommend it to a friend, but would hope the shower is fixed before our return. Thank you!