Overall this was a terrific property, exactly as described, with comfortable beds, fantastic outdoor space, a great hot tub, and almost everything we needed for our stay including quite a few extras (eg. coffee grounds were there, spices, some snacks, etc.) The house is charming with lots of personality and we really enjoyed the shared living spaces.
The inconveniences:
1)There were exactly ten forks, and we had exactly ten people, so we bought some plastic forks to supplement. I do think they should invest in a second set of silverware to supplement for serving purposes (pickles etc), or so that there is extra silverware when the dishwasher is running, etc.
2) There were no bathmats. I don't enjoy getting water all over the bathroom floor.
3) The firepit was not working. This was a big disappointment, as we were really looking forward to using it and to making s'mores. We did contact management and they responded promptly and came to look at it within a few hours, but they were unable to fix it during our stay. They left us a bag of ice pops as compensation (not really a good substitute for s'mores and a working fire pit, but the gesture was appreciated).
4) I think guests should know that the bedroom in the basement is not very private. It is open to the small laundry area as well as the foosball and there are windows that let light in. So to play foosball you have to be in that person's space, and to do laundry you want to make sure you schedule it around their sleep.